Wednesday, October 8, 2014
"Blurred Lines"? Someone Needs Glasses (or Contacts)
Everyone's heard it, everyone has a certain opinion on it, and it's time I gave mine. I feel like I have an opinion that would mainly fall with Ms. Lai's, rather than Ms. Romano, mainly because beyond the title and a slight change in the connotation of her word choice, she's just repeating a few sources about the topic. I feel like there is an element of misogyny in there, but it's also not strictly a rapish kind. The point that Lai makes illustrates this well: "Yes, 'I know you want it' could be said by a rapist—but so could 'Do you want to go to a movie tonight?'"
It's a tick in the male mind that is mainly triggered when they feel like their "masculinity" is impeded upon, and they feel the need to increase the size of their ego in order to "compensate" for the lack of their "manliness". Symptoms of this are putting down other men, mainly by comparing size of muscles, abs, and penises, much of which are done with use of clothes over said body parts, so lying is easier, comparing "hotness" or number of girlfriends, or more likely, girls they've had sex with, and being overall arrogant toerags towards girls in general (winking, touching, or looking suggestively).
There is a cure, however. Talk to your doctor about taking "Com Unsense" (logica). Side-effects include understanding that you aren't God's gift to women, understanding that size doesn't matter, and awareness that sex is best left with a more permanent relationship. Mr. Thicke, Mr. T.I., and Mr. Williams are in clear need of this cure. The lyrics prove that: "Just let me liberate you", "You the hottest bitch in this place", "I'll give you something big enough to tear your ass in two", "He don't smack that ass and pull your hair like that", etc. For that matter, many of my peers can be cured with this not-so-new drug. It's a common theme with high school students, due to the whole "angst" stage. But for a man who clearly is out of high school (just by his stature, not by his maturity or attitude), this is shocking.
But Thicke isn't the only guilty one here. Miley Cyrus, for instance, turned from a well-liked country girl, to a person who thought that cutting her hair into incredibly short pigtails, sticking her tongue out more than Gene Simmons, and wearing underwear that was practical, not sexual, was a good idea. And need I remind you of Nicki Minaj, and her "song", Anaconda, saying that a girl isn't good enough unless her butt's big enough. All of these are clearly trying to make a controversy and gain attention. And you don't have to use sex as a means of that. Shia LaBeouf took the "woe is me" trail when he put that paper bag over his head, whining silently that he wasn't important anymore. Or Lindsey Lohan and her multiple problems, all in an attempt to garner attention.
I think that we won't be able to fully stop incidents like this from happening. There will always be people sadly interested in the lives of celebrities, from them having yet another sex scandal to them going to the loo. And there will be people equally sad enough to cater to this insatiable appetite. TMZ, I'm looking at you. The best we can do is to educate each other that this is unacceptable behavior, whether it is rapey or just looking for attention. Hopefully the lines shouldn't be so blurry there.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Saul, thank you for posting and presenting a male-centric view that held some self-actualization. I have read mostly posts from a number of girls so far and a couple of boys as well, but you really are the only male poster to touch on potentially problematic issues in male culture as being a general problem and not solely incidental.
ReplyDeleteHowever, I have a few issues after such points. First off, you are shaming Miley Cyrus, Shia Lebouf, Lindsey Lohan and others for personal decisions that haven't really harmed anyone, which was a bit unnecessary in making your point. A few of those people are known to be mentally ill or trying to overcome other issues in their lives, so you might want to be a little more sensitive concerning. Secondly, you misinterpreted the point of the song Anaconda. It's about self-love for women who aren't perfectly narrow and flat-figured, as seems to be the coveted body type at this time, and Minaj herself has said it was produced as a counterpoint and challenge to a music industry that's becoming increasingly more and more biased toward women who are not stick thin. Rap and R+B, which used to be all about women with thick thighs and considerable presence of the rear, has even started to direct its attention towards thin women. In short, your fourth paragraph was quite unnecessary and distracted a lot from your main points of the egocentric qualities of male culture that are anything but incidental.
Once again, thank you for contributing your opinion to this discussion. Please be a little more careful in the future about potential misinterpretation.
I have no problem with celebrities making decisions, they're adults. But they also have to accept the responsibilities that go with those choices. As celebrities, a large amount of people follow them, and they have a responsibility to behave. That's why we have so many people with warped ideas of what is socially acceptable. Also, interpretations of music, poetry, and movies can be varied. Look at Robin Thicke. He himself said that he was having fun, pushing the boundaries, and even "empowering women". Others said it was a parody of pop/R+B music. If people believed that the reasons behind music, and any kind of art for that matter, we wouldn't even think that "Blurred Lines" was controversial. I doubt that Anaconda was a parody, not only for the previous reason, but also that Minaj isn't a parody artist. She doesn't parody music enough for that to be viable. However, an artist like "Weird" Al Yankovic, and even the likes of Bo Burnham, would be able to say things like that. They regularly parody societies "backwardsness". In closing, my fourth paragraph wasn't unnecessary. I was talking about Robin Thicke + co. and their choices, but acknowledged that it wasn't a singular event. I could list off a few others, Charlie Sheen, Justin Beiber, even Michael Jackson. In short, "With great popularity comes great responsibility".
DeleteThis is really well-written, Saul. I like your use of quotation marks in the second paragraph. I agree that Lai had more valid points than Romano, but that doesn't mean the song isn't degrading. Unfortunately, this kind of stuff will be around for a very long time, but I have hopes that the misogyny will fade away completely. I also liked how you referenced other artists like Miley Cyrus and Nicki Minaj.
ReplyDelete